MP3 Player Buying Guide

MP3 Player Buying Guide

Last Updated: 10/12/2007

The Basics: MP3 Players

MP3 players were rare just a few years ago, and yet they are ubiquitous today, and their popularity is not expected to wane any time soon. Apple's iPod lineup currently dominates the digital audio player universe, but numerous manufacturers like Creative, SanDisk and iriver, as well as traditional brands such as Panasonic, Sony, JVC and Samsung, produce a wide variety of players, many of which are giving the iPods a run for their money.

The category name of MP3 players is a bit of a misnomer, as many digital audio players can store music files in multiple formats. These may include WMA, WAV, ATRAC, OGG and others, in addition to MP3. iPod has also become a generic name for an MP3 player. This is somewhat ironic, because while iPods can play MP3 files, they primarily operate with AAC files, the format of choice for Apple's popular iTunes Music Store.

MP3 and other formats utilized by digital audio players are data-compression techniques that drastically reduce the size of the original CD music files. This data-reduction amount is variable: a higher reduction rate (i.e., a lower bit rate) results in a smaller file, but the smaller the file, the poorer the sound quality. At higher bit rates (least compressed, best sounding), the sound comes closest to the original CD recording quality. High-quality audio should at least be sampled at 128 kilobits per second (kbps), which results in an MP3 file of about 4MB for a 3- or 3-1/2-minute track. To combat the loss of sound quality, a number of newer digital audio players incorporate technology that helps restore sound details lost during the compression/decompression process.

Digital audio players are available in a multitude of styles, from tiny players that can clip onto your sunglasses or keychain to (relatively) large units that can store tens of gigabytes of music and other content. Many players can hold other types of data (in addition to music files), serving as portable data storage devices. Apple's new video iPods incorporate a small LCD screen for the display of digital video and image files. Competing manufacturers are following suit with screen-equipped MP3 players that can store and play music videos, television shows and even DivX movies. Other MP3 player options include integrated FM tuners, voice microphones, and line inputs that let players record directly from other audio sources. Panasonic even combines an MP3 player with a digital camcorder in some members of its D-Snap line. Quite a few cell phones now incorporate MP3 players, and there are even models with Apple's iTunes software built in.

How to Shop

When shopping for an MP3 player, first consider how much memory you will need. Flash players currently come in capacities of up to 6GB of internal memory, which is enough to hold approximately 192 hours of music (about 2,800 songs), but they are more commonly available with 512MB or 1GB. Hard-disk MP3 players can have as little as 4GB of internal memory or they can hold as much as 60GB, and even larger sizes are no doubt on the horizon. A 60GB MP3 player can store every song in all but the largest music collections. The limiting factor is usually price, but common sense is important too. In general, buy as large a memory as you can afford, but if you only need the space to hold a thousand tunes, there is no reason to spend the extra money for a 40GB player.

If you want a player to listen to while at the gym or out on a jog, check out the many available sports players. These compact units usually utilize Flash memory, which is immune to playback interruptions when jostled, unlike hard-disk systems that don't appreciate being shaken. In addition, sports MP3 players often have handy features such as stopwatches, meters that measure speed and distance, and even water resistance to protect against sweat and rain. Small and light enough to be worn just about anywhere, sports MP3 players usually include clips or arm straps so they can be secured to clothing or the body.

True audiophiles will be interested in the larger-capacity MP3 players. While most users will take advantage of that extra storage space by cramming in more songs, audiophiles know this capacity can be utilized to increase the quality of their music. Higher bit-rate MP3 files take up more memory space, but they'll sound considerably better. Many digital audio players can also handle full-range uncompressed WAV files, which provide true CD-quality sound. A 60GB player can hold about 84 CD worth of music in the uncompressed WAV format.

Make sure a digital audio player comes with the software and cables (usually USB) necessary to connect to your computer. The software usually has two components. The first part is used to convert, or ''rip,'' CD music into MP3 (or other format) files. This is essential for anyone with a large music collection on disc, but if you download a majority of your music from the internet, it isn't as much of a concern. The second component of the software is usually a file manager that helps organize music files into playlists. Once your list is put together, it is a quick and simple process to transfer the music to your portable player.

The weakest link in the portable audio chain is the included headphones or earbuds, which typically provide only marginal audio reproduction. It might be necessary to budget in the price of upgraded headphones when shopping for an MP3 player. Manufacturers are beginning to address this annoying issue by including higher-quality phones in their MP3 player packages, but like all electronics purchases, it is a wise idea to test candidate players (and their headphones) before buying.




Glossary

AMS
Automatic Music Search. This feature allows jumping forward or backward by a desired number of tracks on either tape or CD to hear a specific selection. It is sometimes called autosearch.


Car Adapter
Sometimes called a car-kit, this is a car battery adapter with a cigarette lighter plug and a car stereo cassette adapter--a cassette shell--with a cord that plugs into the CD player's line level output. When loaded into a car's cassette player the output signal is transduced into the tape head for playback through the car's audio system.


Digital tuner/analog tuner
An analog tuner uses conventional circuitry with a tuning knob or thumbwheel and pointer to show you the frequency to which you are tuned. A digital tuner, more accurately a synthesized tuner, permits using a digital frequency read-out and presetting radio stations for touch tuning.


Electronic Shock Protection, Anti-Shock Memory, or Electronic Anti-Shock System (EASS)
These employ computer memory chips that act as an audio buffer. The chips store sound during normal play, and when the laser mistracks from shock or vibration, the chips supply sound from memory until the laser resumes tracking. The disc spins faster than normal to supply sound to the memory buffer. Using this feature shortens battery life considerably, since it requires additional power. It still may not be sufficient to prevent audible mistracking when using a CD player while actively jogging, but it should work for walking, bicycling, and other less jarring activities.


Mega Bass, XBS, or DSL
These are circuits that artificially boost bass to provide a more throbbing sound in headphones. Because many headphones accompanying personal stereos lack good bass response, these circuits may somewhat compensate. However, the bass boost might also muddy sound and increase distortion.


NiCd, NiMH, or Li Batteries
NiCd, or nickel-cadmium, is the most common of rechargeable battery types. It does not store as much power as disposable batteries and needs to be recharged frequently. It also deteriorates if not discharged and recharged properly. The cadmium in nickel-cadmium is highly toxic and environmentally hazardous. NiMH, or nickel metal-hydride, or sometimes just nickel hydride, is a superior alternative to nickel-cadmium. Although double the price, it lasts longer, holds a charge better, is less subject to deterioration from abuse, and is less toxic in landfills. Li, or lithium-ion, is the most advanced rechargeable battery available. It holds a charge much better, lasts far longer than either NiCd or NiMH, and it can be made smaller and lighter than other rechargeable batteries. It can be discharged and recharged without any special procedure or precautions. However, Li batteries cost four to ten times more than NiCd.




Compare Prices on IPods
Apple iPod touch (16 GB, MA627LL/A) Digital Media Player photo
16 GB (Built-in Memory), 4000 Songs, 4.2 oz., Audio Files: MP3, WAV, AAC, MP3 VBR, AIFF, Audible. Video Files: MPEG-4, H.264. Disp...

Stores Selling: 9
$295.00 -
$400.00
Apple iPod nano Third Gen. Silver (4 GB, MA978LL/A) Digital Media Player photo
4 GB (Built-in Memory), 1000 Songs, 1.74 oz., Audio Files: MP3, WAV, AAC, MP3 VBR, AIFF, Audible. Video Files: MPEG-4, H.264. Disp...

Stores Selling: 9
$109.00 -
$150.00
Apple iPod classic Sixth Gen. Black (80 GB, MB147LL/A) Digital Media Player photo
80 GB (Hard Drive), 20000 Songs, 4.9 oz., Audio Files: MP3, WAV, AAC, MP3 VBR, AIFF, Audible. Video Files: MPEG-4, H.264. Display ...

Stores Selling: 8
$237.00 -
$250.00



  Looking for More?


Explanations

Expert Reviews
Apple iPod shuffle (2nd Generation)
Apple iPod nano (3rd generation)
Apple iPod touch
Apple iPod Mini
Apple iPod shuffle MP3 player

Prices
Apple iPod Video Fifth Gen. White (30 GB, MA002LL/A) Digital Media
Apple iPod nano Third Gen. Silver (8 GB, MA247LL/A) Digital Media P
Apple iPod classic Sixth Gen. Black (160 GB, MB150LL/A) Digital Med
Apple iPod nano Third Gen. Green (8 GB, MB253LL/A) Digital Media Pl
Apple iPod mini First Gen. Silver (4 GB, M9160LL/A) MP3 Player



Price Range


Audio Format


Storage Capacity


On Screen Display


Additional Features




Narrow Your Search


Price Range
Below $70 (17)
$70 - $140 (13)
$140 - $190 (16)
$190 - $250 (15)
Above $250 (15)

Audio Format
MP3 (73)
WAV (73)
AIFF (70)
MP3 VBR (68)
Audible (33)

Storage Capacity
At Least 60 GB (8)
At least 40 GB (10)
At least 20 GB (18)
At least 6 GB (35)
At Least 4 GB (47)

On Screen Display
Battery Level (41)
Playlist / Table of Contents (29)
ID3 Tag Info (30)
Elapsed Time (24)
Recharging (12)

Additional Features
Games (28)
Sleep Timer (32)
World Clock (14)
Upgradable Firmware (14)
Personal Address Book (12)

Back to Personal Shopper





Magic Debugger

release: 8.4.3-qa1
content_id: 260759
type: buyingguide
category: l4-cp-ipods

brws title: MP3 Player Buying Guide: Powered by ConsumerGuide and HowStuffWorks

meta d: MP3 players, like the popular iPod, store compressed audio files in flash or hard-disk memory. Pick the perfect player with Consumer Guide’s MP3 Players Buying Guide.

url: http://shopproducts.howstuffworks.com/Apple-iPod-mini-First-Gen-Silver-4-GB-M9160LL-A-MP3-Player/SF-1/PID-21763900